A guest post by Mary Jo Fister and Greg Bush from Offthetrails Paranormal investigations.
The lighthouse, on Anastasia Island, is haunted by two sisters, Mary and Eliza, who drowned in the 1870s; a young girl with the sisters; two lighthouse keepers, and the wife of a keeper who became a keeper after his death –Kate Harn, who wears a long, flowing white dress.
We had several personal experiences there. When we were in the basement of the keeper’s house, Will said, “Will somebody do something?” I felt a finger run along my ankle. One of the keepers is a “ladies man” who likes to touch women.
Soon after, we have a photo of an energy source shooting out of Will’s head, and an elongated white apparition, who we think is Kate, standing nearby. On the staircase of the lighthouse – which has 219 steps- our K2 meter kept spiking as Will held it in his hand.
Pictures show a small orb on the stairway. Was it one of the girls being playful? Matt, who is one of the guides and caretakers, says Mary has a crush on him. Maybe she or her sister was interested in Will.
Click here to see the Lighthouse investigation video.
Click here to visit the St. Augustine Lighthouse website.
Click here to visit Offthetrails Paranormal Investigation
Click on the following for further St. Augustine ghost stories, ghost hunts, haunted cemeteries and more: